Simranjeet Law Associates The Best Side Of Advocates In Chandigarh High Court
The word vest is normally used where an immediate fixed right in present or future enjoyment in respect of a property is created. After having dinner everyone had gone to sleep by about 8:00 p. It is rather the exercise of a police power of regulation in public interest than anything done in the exercise of a power of eminent domain, in which case alone questions relating to compensation and public purpose will arise.
True it is, that the respondent Company which can have no control over the manner of processing of application for sanction by the Corporation cannot be blamed for delay but during pendency of its application for sanction, if the State Government, in exercise of its rule- making power, amended the Building Rules and imposed restrictions on the heights of buildings on G. The vested right or settled expectation has been nullified not only by the Corporation but also by the best lawyer (find out more) State by amending the Building Rules.
Aiyer's Judicial Dictionary (A Complete Law Lexicon), 13th Edn. pension is not to be treated as a bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of the Government and that the right to superannuation pension including its amount is a valuable right vesting in a government servant. There was no requisition of property in this case under section 75 (A) of the Defence of India Rules. Where the evidence showed that a person had died, that his body was found in that the offences under sections 302/34 and 201, Indian Penal Code, being distinct offences committed at two different times and being (1) (I952) 54 P.
That the appeal to the respondent was against the order of the 9th and not against the order of the 8th, and as no appeal lay against the order of the 9th the respondent had no jurisdiction to hear it. The claim based on the alleged vested right or settled expectation cannot be set up against statutory provisions which were brought into force by the State Government by amending the Building Rules and not by the Corporation against whom such vested right or settled expectation is being sought to be enforced.
The Control Order was promulgated under rule 81 (2) (bb) which provides for the regulation of letting and sub-letting houses. Besides this, such a settled expectation or the so-called vested right cannot be countenanced against public best lawyers interest and convenience which are sought to be served by amendment of the Building Rules and the resolution of the Corporation issued thereupon. Nisha, Lakshmi, Sati and Nandini were with their grandmother Kejabai in one room while the appellant, his wife and daughter Sandhya had slept in the adjoining room.
R, 58, 100 separate transactions, the appellant having been convicted of the offence under section 302, Indian Penal Code, only by the Session Judge, the High Court had no jurisdiction when acquitting her of that offence to, convict her under section 201 of the same Code; that the statements of Mohinderpal to 'various witnesses land his conduct were not relevant against the appellant; that advocate in Chandigarh - find out more - Karamchand and Mst. Road and other wards, such settled expectation has been rendered impossible of fulfillment due to change in law.
advocates in advocate Chandigarh (what do you think) Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar, [1971] INSC 141; (1971) 2 SCC 330, decided by a Constitution Bench it has been laid down: (SCC p. 152] (emphasis supplied) In that case the right to receive pension was treated as property under Articles 31(1) and 19(1)(f) of the Constitution. Based on the conclusions drawn in the cited judgment, it was submitted, that a legitimate or a settled expectation, suggesting the possibility of drawing pension after retirement, could not be treated as a vested right.
What we can understand from the claim of a vested right set up by the respondent Company is that on the basis of the Building Rules, as applicable to their case on the date of making an application for sanction and the fixed period allotted by the Court for its consideration, it had a legitimate or settled expectation to obtain the sanction. It was submitted, that the respondent-employees were not justified in raising a claim based on the assumption, that they had a vested right, or settled expectation, under the 1999 Scheme, particularly in the light of the fact, that the 1999 Scheme had been partly nullified, by the notification dated 2.
(3) Where a power of dismissal, whether subject to the sanction of any other authority or not, is conferred by this Act, it shall be deemed to include a power to suspend any person against whom the power of dismissal might be exer- cised, pending enquiry into his conduct or pending the orders of any authority whose sanction is necessary for his dismissal. With the long usage the said word vest has also acquired a meaning as an absolute or indefeasible right [see K. In our considered opinion, such settled expectation, if any, did not create any vested right to obtain sanction.
The context in which the respondent Company claims a vested right for sanction and which has been accepted by the Division Bench of the High Court, is not a right in relation to ownership or possession of any property for which the expression vest is generally used.
